1-800-INSURANCE

City directory

Independent insurance agents in Shrewsbury, MA

Shrewsbury households and business owners trust local agents to navigate carrier appetite shifts, underwriting requirements, and the claims process.

How to choose an independent agent in Shrewsbury

Use this quick checklist when evaluating agencies. Claimed listings on 1-800-INSURANCE display more detail so you can assess fit at a glance.

  • Verify the agency is licensed in your state and handles your lines of coverage.
  • Ask how they shop among national and regional carriers to find savings.
  • Request a renewal review calendar so your policies do not lapse.
  • Confirm how claims are handled and who will advocate for you when something happens.

Verified agencies serving Shrewsbury

These are the first 6 agencies surfaced in our network for Shrewsbury. Verified partners share coverage lines, staffed hours, and story details so you can compare fit before you request an introduction.

Showing 16 of 6 agencies

Dennis P Molinari Insurance

382 Boston Tpke Ste 104, Shrewsbury, MA 01545

Request an introduction through 1-800-INSURANCE to confirm coverage availability in Shrewsbury.

Dennis P Molinari Insurance

382 Boston Turnpike Suite 104, Shrewsbury, MA 01545

Request an introduction through 1-800-INSURANCE to confirm coverage availability in Shrewsbury.

Mancuso-Nowak Insurance Agcy

252 Boston Turnpike, Shrewsbury, MA 01545

Request an introduction through 1-800-INSURANCE to confirm coverage availability in Shrewsbury.

Mccall Insurance Agency

45 SOUTH Quinsigamond Ave., Shrewsbury, MA 01545

Request an introduction through 1-800-INSURANCE to confirm coverage availability in Shrewsbury.

Oak Tree Insurance Agency

714 Main St, Shrewsbury, MA 01545

Request an introduction through 1-800-INSURANCE to confirm coverage availability in Shrewsbury.

Stephen Matthew Mealey Dba Mealey Insurance Agency

PO Box 48, Shrewsbury, MA 01545

Request an introduction through 1-800-INSURANCE to confirm coverage availability in Shrewsbury.

Page 1

Frequently asked questions

Can an independent agent in Shrewsbury, MA help me compare multiple carriers?

Yes. Independent agencies in Shrewsbury, MA partner with a network of national and regional insurers. They can explain the differences in deductibles, endorsements, and discounts so you choose a policy that fits your budget without sacrificing coverage.

What documents should I bring to my first meeting?

Bring current declarations pages for each policy, driver and household information, and details about recent claims. This gives the agent a baseline so they can quote accurately and spot coverage gaps.

How quickly can a local agency activate new coverage?

Most agencies can bind personal lines coverage the same day once they have complete details and underwriting approval. Commercial and specialty policies may require additional carrier review, so starting the conversation early helps avoid delays.

Own an agency in Shrewsbury, MA? Claim your profile to add your logo, team, and insurance lines.

Verified profiles highlight your expertise, keep leads routed through 1-800-INSURANCE, and unlock premium placement above unclaimed listings.

Claim or upgrade your listing